Picking low-cost, high-yield ETFs can feel overwhelming because the choices are massive. I’ve dug through lots of options to put together my own portfolio that keeps costs low but still brings in good income. Figuring out the balance between low fees and high yields helps your money work hard for you rather than getting chipped away by expenses.
If you’re just starting or want to build a sturdy ETF strategy, understanding how to track down these budget-friendly, top-performing funds is key. By choosing wisely, you get to hang onto more of your returns while creating a steady passive income stream for the long haul. Here are the steps I rely on, plus some extra tips and helpful tools I stumbled upon that made the process easier.
Disclaimer: This article contains affiliate links. If you open an account through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of capital. eToro is not available in all countries. Eligibility depends on your region. Always consider your individual circumstances before investing.
Step 1: Figure Out What You Need From an ETF
Every portfolio is unique, and “high yield” may mean something different to you than to someone else. Do you want reliable cash flow, or do you need something that can balance risk better than single stocks? For me, beginning with my goals gave me a clear idea of which ETFs were worth a closer look.
Questions That Help Shape Your Plan:
- What type of yearly income is your target?
- Is your investing horizon long-term, or will you need your money back soon?
- How much risk feels okay to you? Higher yield usually comes along with higher risk.
- Do you prefer dividend payments, or are you after overall returns?
As soon as you figure out your priorities, check out my side-by-side look at low-cost ETFs vs. traditional funds. This resource lays out why cost makes such a difference over time.
Step 2: Focus on Fees and Yield
That perfect ETF combines a low expense ratio with a steady, better-than-average yield. High fees can cut into your returns, even with a solid high-yield ETF, so I always check those expense numbers right away.
How to Spot Low-Cost ETFs:
- Expense Ratio: This represents how much you’ll pay each year for owning the ETF. Numbers under 0.20% are great, but some can go even lower.
- Dividend Yield: Stack up the ETF’s yield against its benchmark index and similar funds. Yields over 3.5% get my attention—as long as they’ve stayed steady for a few years.
I rely on TradingView to sort ETFs by yield and fees; their filters make the process fast and straightforward.
Step 3: Check Out the Holdings and Sector Mix
The actual stocks or assets inside an ETF determine its stability and yield. For example, real estate investment trusts (REITs) and utility stocks often pay stable dividends, but you get sector risk if you’re too concentrated. Broadmarket high-yield ETFs give more safety than niche options, especially if you’re new.
What to Watch For in ETF Holdings:
- Main sectors found in the ETF
- Diversity among industries and regions
- Whether any one stock or industry dominates the fund
If your funds overlap too much, performance can drop fast in a downturn. I always aim for a well-rounded mix instead of a tight cluster in one space.
Step 4: Review ETF Size, Track Record, and Liquidity
I look for at least $500 million in assets under management for high-yield ETFs as my minimum. Bigger funds are simply easier to buy and sell, and they’re priced better. In other words, “bid/ask spreads” are tighter, which saves you money on trades.
Other Factors To Consider:
- Years Running: Funds with five years or more under their belt have shown they can get through choppy markets and keep up good yield data.
- Trading Volume: Funds with higher trading volumes let you buy and sell for less, which means you pay less each time you make a move.
Low trading volume funds can lead to headaches, especially when things get volatile, so it pays to look for good daily activity levels.
Step 5: Compare Platform Choices for Buying ETFs
The place where you buy your ETFs can affect costs and your experience. Things like transaction fees, available features, and even how taxes are handled should all be checked before investing. I bounce between several brokers to find the sweetest spot of pricing and features, and I listed my favorites in my ETF platform guide.
- eToro: Great for beginners and offers plenty of ETF choices. Try eToro
- TradingView: Offers powerful charts and comparison tools for ETFs. Check TradingView
Step 6: Watch Out for Hidden Risks in High-Yield ETFs
Chasing the highest yield can burn you if you miss key risks under the hood. Some high-yield ETFs pile into risky bonds or use complicated methods to raise payouts, and if the market switches up, you might pay the price.
Common Traps to Avoid:
- Too much in junk bonds, emerging markets, or leveraged positions
- Dividend traps: companies with high current payouts but dropping share prices
- ETFs with huge yields that just launched and don’t have a real track record yet
Doing your homework is important and keeps the unpleasant surprises away. Always look closely at what’s actually inside the ETF and past performance across both good and bad years.
Step 7: Revisit and Rebalance When the Market Changes
Your ETF setup isn’t one and done. Things will change—markets move, your needs might switch, or a fund could sneak up its fees. I check on my ETF spread every few months and swap things around if needed. That might mean cashing in some big winners or putting more into those that look good after a drop.
Rebalancing Tips:
- Go over each holding’s yield, expenses, and returns two to four times a year
- Let go of ETFs that no longer match your risk needs
- Remember to review tax impacts before selling and rebalancing
If you want some new ETF picks, see my review of the best high yield ETFs for 2025—it’s loaded with current ideas to check out.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are high-yield ETFs safe for beginners?
They aren’t totally free of risk, but many broad-market high-yield ETFs are a decent choice if you’re after regular payouts. The safest way is to go with well-known funds that have plenty of assets and a long track record.
How much yield should I look for?
This really depends on what you need and how much risk you want to take. Yields above 4% might seem appealing, but they often carry bigger risks. I like keeping a blend of funds that average a steady payout—not just picking whatever looks highest in the moment.
Can I buy low-cost ETFs through any broker?
Nearly any modern trading platform with ETF access will include some good, cheap, high-yield funds. It’s still smart to look up the fees and compare tools between platforms to find the best match for your approach. My roundup of top ETF brokers gives you a great head start.
Putting It All Together
Building your own mix of low-cost, high-yield ETFs takes research, but it really pays you back with steady returns and by slashing excess fees. Start with clear goals, put the spotlight on both expenses and yield, check under the hood at the holdings, and keep on rebalancing when it makes sense.
Quick Start Steps:
- Write down your expected income and comfort with risk.
- Seek trusted ETFs with strong track records, low fees, and consistent yields.
- Spread your assets over different sectors to reduce risk.
- Try out platforms like eToro and TradingView to research new ETF choices.
- Seeing those payouts come in every quarter feels like a job well done, knowing your investments are growing efficiently. If you have more advice or ETF picks, share them in the comments—I’m always excited to dig into fresh names and ideas.